Showing posts with label Holland. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Holland. Show all posts

Friday, March 13, 2026

Green Border (2023)

[2025 review here]

Zielona granica, Poland / France / Czech Republic / Belgium, 152 minutes
Director: Agnieszka Holland
Writers: Maciej Pisuk, Gabriela Lazarkiewicz, Agnieszka Holland
Photography: Tomasz Naumiuk
Music: Frédéric Vercheval
Editor: Pavel Hrdlicka
Cast: Jalal Altawil, Behi Djanati Atai, Maja Ostaszewska, Tomasz Włosok, Mohamad Al Rashi, Dalia Naous, Monika Frajczyk, Piotr Stramowski, Jaśmina Polak, Marta Stalmierska, Maciej Stuhr, Magdalena Popławska, Joely Mbundu, Taim Ajjan, Talia Ajjan

The green border in director and cowriter Agnieszka Holland’s blockbuster, sickening war movie, shot in black and white, is the swampy forested region on either side of the border between Belarus and Poland. A family of Syrian refugees is making their way to Sweden, seeking asylum in the EU. They travel by air to Minsk in Belarus, on the flight picking up Afghani refugee Leila (Behi Djanati Atai), an older woman who is seeking a new home in Poland (rather than wait, as she says, for the Taliban regime to resume power). Belarus is where the problems start for them. They encounter corrupt, sadistic, and/or indifferent officials in the border patrols, thieves, bad weather, and more. Poland unofficially does not allow passage for refugees. Both Poland and Belarus have “pushback” policies, which means Leila and the family are repeatedly herded across the border, back and forth, over and over, between the two countries. Making progress is all but impossible, dependent on luck more than anything.

The family is notably vulnerable. A grandfather in poor health (Mohamad Al Rashi) is the family patriarch, a traditional Muslim who trusts in Allah and rolls out the prayer mat even in the depths of the forest. His grandson Bashir (Jalal Altawil) is more savvy to the world, more embittered, carrying a cell phone that is their lifeline along with powerpacks to keep it charged. His wife Amina (Dalia Naous) and three young children are total innocents who must trust Bashir (and Allah) to get where they are going. The youngest is an infant still being breastfed. Leila has a cell phone too and seems to be the most skilled at using it. She and the oldest boy Nur (Taim Ajjan) make a connection that will turn out to be fatal.

Monday, February 24, 2025

Green Border (2023)

This epic and gripping picture by veteran Polish director and cowriter Agnieszka Holland (Europa Europa, The Secret Garden, Mr. Jones) takes on the humanitarian crisis of Muslim refugees making their way from Syria, Afghanistan, and elsewhere to sanctuary in Sweden (or Poland, or anywhere). The problem is getting there. As Muslims entering the EU they face hostility and prejudice at every point, particularly at this brutal “green border” region that Green Border focuses on between Belarus and Poland. It is heavily forested and the terrain can be rugged and swampy. Both Belarus and Poland have semi-official “pushback” policies, which means the refugees are continually moved back and forth across the barbed wire by violent border patrols. Laws obviously don’t matter here. Green Border offers a sprawling set of characters and stories, focusing on the border patrols and activists working on the scene as well as the refugees. Of course it’s worst for the refugees, but the activists are laboring under dire conditions too and we see that even the border patrols, or those not particularly psychopathic, are under tremendous contradictory pressures themselves. The stories and situations are complex as they unravel in this swirling stew. One thing keeps leading to another. It’s often nighttime. The screenplay is rich with the difficulties of individual circumstances, a constant high-wire act. It bears elements of The Grapes of Wrath in the story of one family. The black and white film stock only makes it more stark, the shadows are deeper, darker, and the glimmers of light more fleeting and elusive. It’s hard to watch in places because Holland’s characterizations are drawn so fine these people just come alive even as they are grievously wounded or worse. The middle-aged Leila (Behi Djanati Atai) haunts me, fleeing Afghanistan from the specter of the Taliban. Her big glasses, her deft use of her cell phone, her compassion and generosity, and her fate are deeply felt, searing. The final scenes compare all we have seen in a long movie with the more recent treatment of 2 million Ukrainian refugees after the Russia-Ukraine War started. They are welcomed to Poland even as the inhumane treatment and atrocities continue on the green border. Heartbreaking portrait of a horrible situation but the movie is never less than enthralling. Double feature with Come and See, if you can stand it.