Saturday, November 21, 2026

Trust (1981)

I don’t listen to Elvis Costello (nee Declan MacManus) much anymore, though I was a reasonably ardent fan from the beginning through Spike in 1989. I still pull out This Year’s Model from time to time (“pull out,” listen to me, I mean I stream it of course), which amazingly has never lost any of its immediacy or power, even in alternate versions. Every one is stellar. That reminds me, the best portrait of Costello is Nick Kent’s profile piece in NME from August 1977—it’s the Elvis C. who put together This Year’s Model. From then on his albums were always a little bit of work for me, though I came to like some of them very much, such as Armed Forces and Get Happy!!, predecessors to Trust. But I always had to listen a few times to get the lay of the land on his intricate-seeming albums. Trust, to be honest, I missed entirely at the time due to life events of 1981. I caught up with it later, but I have never entirely felt I had a bead on it and I return to it in puzzlement now and then. The songwriting is all over the place, with multiplicities of pop song styles and his endemic increasingly cringy because so obviously reflexive wordplay, e.g., “She’s got eyes like saucers, oh you think she’s a dish.” There’s certainly a good argument here for the Attractions, which are fully credited. Keyboardist Steve Nieve notably stands out on “Lover’s Walk” and elsewhere—I like him best when he’s pounding a piano. The rhythm section, notably drummer Pete Thomas, can also be noticeably good. I see that Trust seems almost unusually well regarded—the Wikipedia article is long and detailed for an album page, and rock critic Robert Christgau awards it a relatively infrequent full A. The only other Costello album that gets one is This Year’s Model. I can’t agree Trust is as good as that. I’m not even sure it’s one of his better albums. It always seems to puzzle me as more or less standard-issue Elvis C. I like hearing from Glenn Tilbrook on “From a Whisper to a Scream” because it reminds me how much I like him in Squeeze. The high drama of “Shot With His Own Gun” seems to me more like same old same old at this point. The infidelity and the rage are just mannered. I would put Get Happy!!, his semi-apologia for the stupid Bramlett incident, well ahead of Trust, possibly second only to This Year’s Model—still, now, always, the one to turn to if it has to be just one.

No comments:

Post a Comment